Determinacy of Structures: Explained in 2-minutes

Stable structures can either be statically determinate or indeterminate, which affects how we can solve them. But how do we determine the degree of determinancy?
Fri 23rd Sep 2022 by ilyas

If the reactions of internal forces of a structure can be solved using just the force equilibrium equations, we refer to it as (i) statically determinate. If the structure is more complicated but still stable, we refer to it as (ii) statically indeterminate. Both of these are stable structures. In the latter case, we can consider compatability conditions to help us solve complex problems.

Besides there two categories, there is a third classification for structures which are inherently (iii) unstable (such as a cantilever beam with a pinned end). This third classification is also referred to as a mechanism.

This post explains how to assess the determinancy of a structure.


Determinancy of a Beam

We can determine the degree of determinancy for a beam using the following equation:

degree of determinancy, d equals r minus left parenthesis n plus e subscript c right parenthesis

Where r is the number of reactions, n is the number of equilibrium equations (3), and ec is the additional equilibrium equations due to internal hinges or internal rollers.


NOTE:    Each internal hinge carries an ec value of 1
                Each internal roller carries an ec value of 2


We can interpret the determinancy as follows:

d < 0Mechanism
d = 0Statically determinate
d > 0Statically indeterminate


Some examples of calculating determinancy of various structures are shown below.

230326_cantileverDeterminancy.JPG


Determinancy of a Frame Structures

Some examples of calculating determinancy of frames is shown below:

230326_momentFrameDeterminancy.JPG


Determinancy of Arch Structures

Some examples of calculating the determinancy of arches is shown below:

230326_archDeterminancy.JPG

NOTE: This method does not work for structures with closed loops.




Further Information

You can find more information at the links below:

https://learnaboutstructures.com/External-Indeterminacy

https://wethestudy.com/engineering/determinacy-structural-analysis/



Last Update 25/01/26 10:46 JST

 
1 person found this article helpful.


SIMILAR ARTICLES
 
REFERENCES
No references...
COMMENTS




Total no. of posts: 251
Unique visits on this page: 1215
Copyright Notice
Website Disclaimer

© ilyas.jp 2022-2025